Where do you stand on this whole "Rose shattered PD" thing? So many online theories, my head hurts. (honestly I kinda think Lion is PD... don't hurt me)

Anonymous

I’ve seen a lot of theories about it being someone else who shattered her but I think Rose was definitely the person who did it. Garnet pretty much confirmed it. The only other theory about it I kinda like is that it was actually Pearl who shattered PD and Rose covered for her but I’m not totally convinced on that. 

I’d like to see a flashback or at least have a more detailed explanation of what actually happened. I doubt Rose planned to shatter PD in advance. My guess is that she tried to talk to her first and shattered her out of desperation. Context is important. But I like this reveal that Rose was not pure and perfect. It gives Steven an opportunity to be better than her like Bismuth said he was. Rose shattered PD because she saw it as the only option, Steven will most likely work to change the diamond’s minds without killing anyone. 

As for Lion, personally I like the theory that they’re a corrupted pearl. The pocket dimension makes a lot of sense that way. I haven’t seen any explanation for Lion being PD though and I can’t think of anything myself but maybe i’m missing something. 

  1. xxxspacexxx reblogged this from awyadraws
  2. awyadraws posted this